THREE DAYS LEFT
ALL-AMERICAN GUY's house is located to the right of KEL'S HOUSE, and he can only be interacted with once KEL and SUNNY agree to retrieve the PHOTO ALBUM. He can be found sitting on the couch in the living room watching TV. He'll ask for the boys to help find his TV REMOTE. This first instance is easy to spot - right under the couch. He rewards the party with a can of ORANGE JOE.
TWO DAYS LEFT
In the afternoon, after bringing BASIL home, he'll ask to help find the remote again - he recalls going to the bathroom before it went missing. Sure enough, the remote is on the towel rack in the bathroom of his house. Again, he rewards the party with ORANGE JOE.
ONE DAY LEFT
In the morning, after paying a visit to AUBREY'S HOUSE, the man needs help once again. He recalls falling asleep before the remote disappears. An unknown set of circumstances has led to the remote being baked in one of his wife's pies in the kitchen. Miraculously, it still works, and the man rewards the party with one last can of ORANGE JOE. Finding his remote all three days contributes to the Universally Loved achievement.